How to get a Phantom Plushie

You have to go to a den with the rare claw in it, and click on the rare claw. Next, play the claw. Proof you can get Phantom Plushies from it:

While Snowyclaw has a rare claw in their den, I suggest going to clark's den instead. Going to Snowyclaw's den will cause lag, while going to clark's won't cause any. If you don't get a Phantom Plushie the first try, don't give up! Instead, keep playing the claw and you'll get one! :D